When I reach the end of an essay’s introduction, I want a clear sense of what the writer is inviting me to think about. A question is enough. So is a situation that makes me want to understand more.
What makes writing an introduction difficult is that we often need to write our way toward our subject. We might start with expository background, work through a few general observations, and eventually arrive at the idea that first made us want to write the essay.
When we edit, though, we may discover that those opening paragraphs helped us find our way into the essay. That doesn’t mean the reader needs all of them. We did. The reader needs something more direct.
Suppose I am writing an essay about learning to accept criticism. I might begin with broad statements about how writers throughout history have struggled with criticism. But maybe I could begin closer to what actually bothers me: “Even though I agreed with every suggestion I got from my editor, I was still angry.” Right there, I have something emotional and tangible to explore.
Maybe I could then explain why useful advice might make someone angry. Or maybe I could explore what anger reveals about the gap between wanting to improve the manuscript and being willing to do the extra work to make the changes, even when I thought it was finished.
A clear introduction can leave these questions open. It also gives the reader and me enough direction to recognize and understand why the next paragraph matters. If I’m writing a more argument-based essay, that direction might require stating my central claim more directly. In a personal reflection, an unresolved moment may be all I need. We can discover what we mean as we write. In revision, we need to make sure the reader can follow how we got there.
If you write essays, try this on a draft. Underline or bold the first sentence that makes you curious about your subject, then look at everything that comes before it. In those opening lines, identify what the reader must know before reaching that underlined sentence. To get the reader to the point of the essay quickly, move or remove any sentences that can wait or are unnecessary. We want the reader to reach the question or experience we’re exploring while they’re still curious enough to follow us. You may discover that your beginning is sitting halfway down the first page.
A clear beginning gives the reader a place to enter the discussion. Once they are there, you can furnish the room as you go.